Window 2025-11-02 → 2026-10-30 (11.9 months) · all times UTC · capability demo, not a validated strategy
Rates with their uncertainty
Measure
All (12 months)
Discovery (first 70%)
HOLDOUT (last 30%)
Independent alerts (4 of 5)
7
4
3
Completion rate (alerts reaching step 5)
4/7 = 57% 95% CI 25%–84%
2/4 = 50% 95% CI 15%–85%
2/3 = 67% 95% CI 21%–94%
Win rate (wins ÷ closed outcomes)
1/4 = 25% 95% CI 5%–70%
1/2 = 50% 95% CI 9%–91%
0/2 = 0% 95% CI 0%–66%
Best move after entry (median R, middle half)
1.2R (0.8–1.7)
1.9R (1.5–2.4)
0.8R (0.6–1.1)
Worst move after entry (median R, middle half)
0.6R (0.2–1.6)
0.6R (0.4–0.7)
1.9R (1.0–2.8)
Failure modes (completed / lost / invalidated / expired)
4 / 3 / 0 / 3
2 / 1 / 0 / 2
2 / 2 / 0 / 1
Every rate shows successes/n and a 95% Wilson interval. n is the number of INDEPENDENT setups (sequences on the same swing or zone within 24 H1 candles count once). With samples this small the intervals are wide - read them, not the point values.
How often the setup formed
Level
Raw sequences
Independent setups
Per month
Watch
37
25
2.1
Alert
14
7
0.59
Complete
10
4
0.34
25 independent setups reached Watch, 7 reached Alert and 4 completed over 11.9 months (about 0.59 alerts a month).
Across 4 completed setups the median best move was 1.2R and the median worst move 0.6R (middle half: 0.8 to 1.7R best, 0.2 to 1.6R worst).
Trading sessions (discovery item preview)
Each session holds only 2 alerts (Asia), 2 alerts (London), 3 alerts (NewYork), 0 alerts (Off-hours); the intervals overlap, so no session difference is established.
Holdout
Discovery: 4 alerts, completion 50%, win 50%. Holdout: 3 alerts, completion 67%, win 0%. Samples this small cannot separate the two.
Control: is it better than random timing?
The setup does NOT clearly beat the random-timing control (its interval overlaps it). Control = same 2R-before-1R rule at random times matching hour-of-day and ATR(H1). Control trades overlap, so treat its interval as optimistic.
Discovery list (kept apart from Whits's own rules)
ID
Finding
Holdout result
Status
RC-001
Completion rate by trading session
not enough discovery-period data to form a claim
failed
RC-002
Win rate by trading session
not enough discovery-period data to form a claim
failed
RC-003
Deeper sweeps follow through further (median MFE in R)
discovery period has too few completed setups to form a claim
failed
Findings are written to results/research_candidates.csv as “unvalidated”, tested only on the holdout, and never change an alert until Whits approves them in writing. Findings that fail stay on the list marked “failed”.